Is bouldering or lead climbing more dangerous reddit. Reddit's rock climbing training community.

Is bouldering or lead climbing more dangerous reddit. Does anyone know of the data to compute such an answer? I'd also be curious to compare different types of climbing I started indoor bouldering 2 months ago, knowing that I have a pretty big fear of heights and that it will be a challenge to overcome that. This usually happens when climbing outside more often than not, but there have been deaths (although uncommon) indoors. But call me a nihilist, so is life in general (maybe except for the ‘natural’ part). Lead climbing is clearly inferior to top roping. Let’s explore the dangers of rock and lead climbing, top roping, and bouldering. But as we all know, even the experienced among us make mistakes 90 votes, 182 comments. A couple of months just before I started rope climbing (had only been bouldering for a few years prior) there was an incident in another gym where the auto belay failed and the person fell to their death. I also think the difference between indoor and outdoor bouldering is far greater than with indoor/outdoor climbing. Bouldering is short, intense climbing. Ive noticed I can rock climb something easy and not be scared until I reach near the top but as the climb increases in difficulty the fear starts kicking in sooner. You can find more details on this and how to safely use your equipment in our article here. Aug 8, 2024 · How do they go about preventing injury? Per USA Climbing’s National Team Physical Therapist and Medical Manager, Zack DiCristino, bouldering is the most injury-prone of the three Olympic disciplines, followed by lead climbing and, after a significant gap, speed. Lead climbing involves climbing taller walls with a rope for safety. Just stay away from bouldering and, depending on how bad your injury/pain is, lead climbing and you should be fine. There are still risks involved in lead climbing when you are pregnant. And finally, once you think you are hooked, the variability in the types of climbing, yes, from route to route, or location to location, but mostly top rope climbing to lead climbing to trad climbing to aid climbing to big wall climbing! Jul 3, 2024 · Is rock climbing dangerous? Rock climbing is not considered a particularly high risk sport when practised safely. All that wasted time dragging around ropes and climbing routes below your potential. Even at nationals, the sheer number of competitors is so much higher in bouldering its bound to be more competitive. Data suggests the odds of dying while rock climbing are well behind the likes of swimming, cycling and even running. The people I know who progress pretty quickly at lower grades on rope split time between bouldering and roped climbing-- progressively shifting towards more bouldering as a percentage of training as their roped climbing grades have gone up. Although an argument can be made that indoor climbing or even outdoor sport climbing is relatively safe, climbing is dangerous, pointless, and unnatural. Need to boulder at least once a week to maintain. There are lead climbing harnesses you can buy especially for women who are pregnant. . Sounds dumb and obvious, but this realization totally changed my climbing and if you're a TR warrior with outdoor goals, it could change yours. Are people falling on little kids in the bouldering room daily? How often… Why spend 100 dollars a new pair pants a shirt when you can get a new cam or two. The problem? I become nearly paralyzed with anxiety about actually climbing lead routes. com Rock climbing, with its breathtaking ascents and jaw-dropping vistas, is a pursuit that beckons adventure enthusiasts from around the world. I've seen many, many more expecting mothers on top rope than I have in the bouldering cave, which I attribute to the risks to your baby due to impact from falling. It is, however, more dangerous because climbers do not have the safety of a rope. #2 Lead climbing comps (spoken from my own experience so take it with a grain of salt) are noticeably less competitive than bouldering ones at most levels of competition. This is usually caused by more experienced climbers acting cocky and forgetting to attach certain pieces of equipment into the wall. Oct 19, 2023 · Discover the dangers associated with rock climbing and learn how to mitigate the risks to ensure a safe and enjoyable experience. So viewers can be forgiven for having questions about how the event works and what’s going on and why these large-forearmed people are doing what they’re doing. Just did White Maiden's Walkway the other weekend and I completely understand what you mean about bailing. Dedicated to increasing all our knowledge about how to better improve at our sport. Jun 18, 2021 · Rock climbing has risks, but it’s not as dangerous as other extreme sports. Or if you're a cowboy and wrapping ropes around dead trees and shit to rappel. The padding has a lot of vertical give, but your shoes are grippy so there is almost no lateral give. Rock climbing can be an exhilarating hobby, and it is becoming more popular around the world. Well done! Reply reply Hokus • we did it reddit Reply reply More repliesMore replies Supersquigi •• Edited The rock has probably been there for at least few hundred thousand years though I see that I have made a dangerous mistake Reply reply [deleted] • I've worked for multiple climbing gyms over the past 10 years. I forced myself to do some today but didn't leave feeling any better about it--actually managed to psych myself out on a top rope route after that. You only have to worry about differences in weight of a belayer and their climber, and that is more significant of an issue when the heavier person is the lead climbing as opposed to top roping. For example, back clipping can be dangerous. I have watched many of my guy friends with more natural upper body strength who have been climbing less time than me overtake me grade-wise pretty quickly. Her lead climbing, however, lags significantly behind her world-class bouldering skills, even more so than the other bouldering specialists on this list. climbing gyms are great, they provide an outlet to climb when you might not have access to local outdoor climbing areas. Even those who don't care at all about performance on boulders. Hi there, first time poster in this sub, recently started climbing more and more, but yesterday I encountered a problem that mainly relied on balance and footwork for the first half. DiCristino sees finger maladies more than any other injury. My climbing partners don't seem to fall as often as me - I do think I push myself harder/am willing to take more risks, but I can't tell if this is a good thing or just dangerous. And yes we are scared of falling. I was wondering how dangerous falling down can be, assuming you fall and hit the ground "correctly" (rolling onto your back). And it happens more than you realize, because people think "I can never understand how you do that", so they get complacent. Hi there, I want to get back into bouldering after having tried it a few times already, but I remember being quite scared of falling down the last times. You also generally pull much more difficult single moves, which makes it easier to strain muscles and tendons. Which meant that when I climbed outdoor I didn't think I could specifically climb certain grades. Climbing down is safer and if you climb down the same problem you did you get more endurance work in Are people not “real” surfers if they’re scared of big waves or dangerous areas? Climbing very obviously means different things to different people, and just like there is a difference between mountaineering and climbing, there’s a difference between climbing for the exposure / risk, and climbing for the physical/difficulty asked. I was wondering how dangerous the gym really is. If you don't have good footwork, you could really end up hurting yourself with a nasty ropeburn if you fall wrong. Also surprisingly durable for a high performance shoe, lasted 8 months before I resoled them could have probably pushed it another month or 2. 10 pushups is difficult for me. Bouldering in a gym is much riskier than TR or lead in terms of injury, but TR or lead are riskier in that when something DOES go wrong, the results are generally much worse. They aren't easier/more difficult, they are just different disciplines using different grading scales. Oh, I certainly agree that you're more likely to injure yourself bouldering than you are to die while roped climbing. 12 outside you might want to consider bouldering more than lead climbing, as generally progressing to higher grades is essentially solving boulder problems on the route. I'm pretty new to bouldering and have already taken a few unexpected falls from the top or close to the top, including a kind of scary sideways one today. Mainly because it's so pumpy and sustained overhanging. If I had a nickel for every climber at my gym taking 30 mins to lead a 5. But, I have been lead trad climbing for literally 50 years this month. The places I climb outdoors tend to be vertical to less than vertical, with only short sections where you need to pull a bulge or small roof. The following analysis, and pie chart, exclude alpine and mountaineering incidents, which represent a separate climbing discipline with added dangers, and which deserve further study. Feb 14, 2022 · In an examination of all roped rock-climbing accidents, trad climbers reported about three times the number of accidents as sport and toprope combined. In the gym where I climb they recommend no more than a 30% weight difference for lead climbing and prohibit anything over a 50% weight difference. Nov 27, 2023 · To conclude, top rope climbing and lead climbing are two popular rock climbing styles, each with its own set of challenges and rewards. Hell, the previously mentioned partner actually broke his ankle bouldering last year. Oct 20, 2024 · Is bouldering more physically demanding than lead climbing? Bouldering tends to be more intense over short bursts, while lead climbing requires sustained effort over longer periods. Yes all climbing is inherently dangerous. Dec 22, 2022 · Lead falls are an indispensable part of rock climbing. My boyfriend has a lot of experience with belaying, although not in a traditional Reddit's rock climbing training community. So keep reading to learn more. Nov 30, 2019 · Climbing has a reputation as a dangerous sport —and rightfully so. If you are spinning, even just a tiny bit, it makes the impact much more dangerous. Oct 16, 2021 · What are the main hazards of rock climbing, and exactly how dangerous is rock climbing when compared to other sports? I am very afraid of heights, but I have been climbing (bouldering/lead) for several years and there's definitely a difference in my comfort level so much so that I now regularly climb up 90+ feet on lead and on boulders over 15-20 feet tall! So, what’s the difference between top roping and lead climbing? Top roping you’re supported from above, while lead climbing you’re always above your rope. Why Do People Climb If There is a Risk of Death or Serious Injury? I have also been climbing on and off for about a decade, trad more consistently for the past few years, I lead 10b sport and 5. Mar 4, 2022 · Bouldering outdoors is an easy way to do some solo rock climbing outside; however, it’s naturally more dangerous than an indoor gym. And even 5. I would say that the Alpine climber capable of climbing The Grand Teton is less likely to be killed climbing a 5. In other words if you were to spend an hour climbing (sport lets say) or an hour driving a car, which one is more likely to kill you? I've a friend that finds the idea of rock climbing very dangerous but I suspect it might not be any more dangerous than driving to work. The truly dangerous stuff is when you're lead trad climbing on a rout that doesn't allow much in the way of placing cams or nuts. Lead climbing and rappelling injuries tend to be more severe and/or fatal. For sport climbing, it's good for endurance and static climbing. If injury and death are what's being judged, I would say that roped climbing is more dangerous (excluding highballs). Personal experience? I know I have the "New Climber" tag in this sub (It's a personal joke). The starting bouldering grades are also more challenging than starting top-roping routes because there’s no safety equipment. Fast clipping makes lead climbing so much Over the last few weeks at the climbing gym there have been a number of accidents, mostly beginner climbers falling off the wall and getting pretty seriously hurt (broken bones in a couple of cases). Sport climbing= Climbing with a Harness and clipping the the rope into the wall as you go up. One thing that would be even better is if they gave some type of course for their membership that helped them respect the outdoor climbing resource. I want to enjoy bouldering because many of my friends prefer it over top rope climbing but it’s just so scary to me. For bouldering, your knees will thank you. In this blog, I will demonstrate the differences between these two types of climbing. Alpine & mountaineering are in a different class altogether. I'm sure you could still send routes that don't require absolutely correct positioning to, say, gain proper leverage on a crimp etc. Ask any performance-oriented sport or trad climber and they’ll tell you: become comfortable with big, safe falls if you want to reach your full climbing potential. I have also been climbing on and off for about a decade, trad more consistently for the past few years, I lead 10b sport and 5. Death Death can be caused when rock climbing due to complacency. (1) Key Takeaway Bouldering is You only have to worry about differences in weight of a belayer and their climber, and that is more significant of an issue when the heavier person is the lead climbing as opposed to top roping. Over 70% of injuries in climbing are because of bouldering rather than other types such as lead climbing. Each time I just went to do my thing, talked to people who were there and gradually, over time seeing the same people again and again and having more to talk about. These are full body harnesses which give you more support than a normal lead harness. That’s why bouldering is more approachable to beginners. Compared to most other climbing-related activities, indoor bouldering is probably one of the safest ones out there. It is just not preferred or recommended often to beginners, because if you have access to a gym, then clearly by climbing more you can gain a lot more and make a lot more progress. This makes lead climbing both more dangerous and more difficult. Why do you think lead had more impacted on your back? You do need a good belayer offcourse. Interested in lead climbing? Want to learn more about it? Learn everything you need to know with this definitive lead climbing guide for beginners. People start running laps and get tired and forget to clip in, or just get into the flow of the climbing, or are really focused on their footwork. God damn it was so much fun. So yeah, downclimbing is pretty decent. 1. Consisting of strenuous moves and usually less than 25 feet off the ground. Well I started lead climbing because it has way less overal impact on my whole body. Sport climbing you are generally caught by a rope when you fall, and don't make super hard single moves. For alpine, it can be the thing that determines whether you live or die. Always read the route before you get on it. 12s can have great nearly no hands rests in them. When it comes to rope climbing on outdoor rock (as opposed to bouldering or free soloing), climbers usually employ one of two general styles. Let’s delve into the sobering aspects of this Aug 9, 2024 · While speed climbing, lead climbing, and bouldering are nothing new, Olympic Sport Climbing—the category under which all three sports are arranged—wasn’t a thing until 2021. In my experience, It happens to experienced climbers more than anyone. Roped climbing in any form takes more equipment- harness, rope, helmet, belay device and eventually QuickDraws and stuff to make anchors if you are going to sport or top rope outside. Top rope/lead climbing will increase your endurance a lot imo. The home of Climbing on reddit. Fast clipping makes lead climbing so much So recently I've become interested in climbing, not really outdoor climbing atm but climbing in the gym looks pretty fun. not to mention my rock climbing group next year was talking about learning to do lead climbing which sounds absolutely terrifying! do you have any tips for getting over bouldering/falling fears? Feb 26, 2025 · Discover the key differences between bouldering vs lead climbing, including gear, risks, techniques, and which style suits you best. 8 (5. Too many people abusing this resource these days. However, due to the nature of rock climbing, you may be wondering if it's safe to do so if you're overweight. Dealing with fear is a very common theme in climbing, all the way from being afraid of bouldering heights to being afraid of taking big whippers when lead climbing advanced grades. Jun 4, 2020 · Not Using Equipment Properly When lead climbing there are certain ways of using your gear that is more effective and safer than others. So recently I've become interested in climbing, not really outdoor climbing atm but climbing in the gym looks pretty fun. The article illustrates that there are a lot of people getting outside who don't have much of a clue what they're doing and make foolish mistakes. General insight: footwork is everything with lead climbing. And there is plenty of less dangerous climbs. However, like any sport, it carries its own set of risks, and understanding the causes of fatalities in rock climbing is crucial for climbers to navigate these challenges safely. However, the risks associated with rock climbing, as with many outdoor pursuits, do mean that an accident can be fatal. Outdoors is rock/projects. Hangboarding is not inherently dangerous for beginners, if done correctly, it is one of the safest things you can do as a climber. While climbing up high with a belay is absolutely something I want to try, bouldering looks particularly interesting to me due to it's short but more intense bursts of technical puzzles. Top rope climbing is generally regarded as a safer and more beginner-friendly climbing style, whereas lead climbing requires a higher level of technical skill and experience. It is very important that we know climbing can be dangerous, and this situation can end up being a net positive in your growth as a climber , because it is forcing you to really think about the safest way to do things. Note: This is coming from someone who mainly climbs trad so take the above for however much you think it's worth. In every single gym the accident log binder is overflowing with injuries due to bouldering (mostly bad landings), while injuries from roped climbing (top rope or lead) are scarce. However, it still requires a belayer and can be more physically taxing because of the longer routes. The same goes for bouldering. Recently I've been going outdoor for bouldering a lot more, and I've been getting a lot better at the outdoor specific skills (footwork, irregular holds, etc. This is why you need to really focus on your safety before and while you go on your solo climbing journey. I'm a year into climbing (gym, top rope) and recently learned and tested so I can lead climb at my gym. If you are 5. You’re likely to go to a more remote location and, as such, be exposed to the elements. Feb 21, 2025 · Bouldering allows climbers to concentrate on power and technique while also presenting a mental and physical challenge. Bouldering= (typically) Short climbs that don't require a harness or rope. That was spent climbing at different walls, doing bouldering, lead, training etc. Bertone has yet to make a World Cup lead finals appearance. I suppose most of our climbing on single pitch stuff in the north of England which is probably less dangerous than elsewhere but if someone did fall from 10/15 metres on to rocks I'm sure they could be seriously injured or even killed but I don't know anyone who tries really difficult climbing without good gear. I started splitting my time between top rope and bouldering at my gym. The falls have been mostly from high up on the wall, usually on ‘sketchy finish moves’. I think breathing patterns and shaking arms out where there is an easy rest spot also plays a big factor. Mar 9, 2022 · From mountaineering and ice climbing to rock climbing and bouldering, all of these disciplines have their own specialized gear and demand that their practitioners master different skill sets. However, if something were to go wrong, you are 30+ ft off the deck, and falling to the ground involves serious broken limbs or death Mar 19, 2023 · Bouldering and lead climbing may seem similar but there are distinct differences between the two styles that make them unique. ) One of the big things I adapted to was the greater degree of risk outdoors (bad landing, less padding, trusting spotter), and as I've been climbing more my fear response has gotten muted. If it is in fact dangerous, I'd appreciate some advice on how to tackle my fear and go climbing regardless😅 Thanks! It’s great that bouldering is so accessible, and I hate the idea of placing obstacles in the way of that. 7 at the Gunks than while doing an epic back country alpine route. Bouldering is about climbing shorter routes without ropes, using crash pads for safety. My boyfriend has a lot of experience with belaying, although not in a traditional Dec 17, 2023 · Image by: climbingport. But since it's a very individualistic sport, you can only take the chances you want to take. It took me a pandemic to realize I should exclusively lead climb in the gym if I want to be a better lead climber outdoors. Don't go way over, that can lead to reinforcing the fear, instead start off with something completely comfortable and go from there. The solution is still my favorite sport climbing shoe that I have tried, precise and makes me feel confident on even the smallest feet. However, the normal harness used is not usually suitable for pregnant women. And when you read the route, include the clips with it, including body position for the most effective clipping position. Last year 204 accidents resulting in 210 injuries and 22 deaths were reported to Accidents in North American Climbing (ANAC), a Every fall is a ground fall while bouldering. 7 trad and also haven't fallen on gear yet XD Also in socal currently cutting my teeth in tahquitz. The real distinction between top roping and lead climbing is the belay system used. Jun 16, 2021 · Bouldering is much harder than top roping because it requires more strenuous and dynamic moves to send a route. Your chances of taking a life-altering injury, or even breaking a bone, are fairly low. With that being said, though, it can still happen Oct 19, 2023 · Discover the dangers associated with rock climbing and learn how to mitigate the risks to ensure a safe and enjoyable experience. Indoor climbing is inherently safer - outdoor you are more aware of the risk you are taking (lead I know there's an abundance of people who blame strength over technique, but the reality is I can't do a single pull-up. Listen to your body. I will also highlight the advantages and disadvantages of each style. I reckon the ratio is AT LEAST 15 bouldering injuries for every roped climbing injury. Every time. 3K votes, 260 comments. 3M subscribers in the climbing community. Knowing the differences between these two styles can help climbers choose the best style for them. Same, I love indoor bouldering, but indoor lead climbing is harder for me than outdoors. Ive been rock climbing for 2 months. However, just as any sport climbing venue requires you to show a basic degree of competency, maybe bouldering walls need to adopt similar measures, and respond more appropriately when people behave in dangerous ways. My question for you is what do you love about climbing and what are you willing to give up? For me, bouldering is way more fun and gives me a spark of joy that TR just If we're going solely on injuries, than bouldering absolutely beats out roped climbing. Rope climbing is long, steady climbing at a much "lower" V grade equivalent that take insane amounts of endurance and strategy to get through in one shot. You aren't being irresponsible to your climber (they know they weigh more than you) but not all gyms would allow it. Reply reply Totallynotjohan • Reply reply julmod- • Reply reply more replyMore replies wallClimb7 • Reply reply Svenflex42 • Dec 10, 2024 · Bouldering and lead climbing are two exciting ways to climb rocks. Bertone burst onto the World Cup scene with exceptional finishes in the bouldering events right out of the gates. Good job. Both styles offer adventure and growth. Top rope climbing is safer than bouldering. 10 in your gym), I’d just start bouldering. Because of the increased fall distance and all of the risks associated with it, lead climbing is probably the riskiest activity that most climbers will do. Reddit's rock climbing training community. So, is lead climbing dangerous? Lead climbing is one of the most dangerous forms of rock climbing, and requires a skilled climber/belayer to be performed safely. So, is indoor bouldering dangerous? Indoor bouldering has a medium risk level for mild injuries, and a low risk level for serious injuries. I started when climbing was a lot more dangerous. gdc mlm huv dwg jnxa kbnsdpy foxbe sxamak lwi yfjidwpv